• About
  • Archives
  • Advertising

NYCPPNEWS

NYC Production & Post News

  • Home
  • Directory Listings
    • The Standby Program
    • Brooklyn College
    • Brooklyn Workforce Innovations
    • Columbia University Film Program
    • Downtown Community Television Center
    • Electronic Arts Intermix
    • Film Biz Recycling
    • Freelancers Union
    • Independent Filmmaker Project
    • Manhattan Edit Workshop
    • Mediakite Training Center
    • New York Film Academy
    • New York Film/Video Council
    • New York Institute of Technology
    • New York Production Alliance
    • New York Video School
    • New York Women in Film & Television
    • NYU Film & Television
    • Post New York Alliance
    • The Independent Film School
    • International Film Institute of New York
    • The New School – Documentary Studies
    • The New School — MA in Media Studies
    • Union Docs
    • Upstate Independents
    • Syracuse Film Office
Home » How Cinema 4D Conquered Manhattan – Part III

How Cinema 4D Conquered Manhattan – Part III

Mantra Design’s Christopher McCard used Maxon’s Cinema 4D
for this intro to MTV’s Video Music Awards.
Photo credit: Maxon

A Multi-Part Series by Joe Herman

Part III: The Uber Designer

Dan Ochiva contributed to this report.

Part I gave a short background to CGI on the Mac, partly to give some background behind the popularity of Maxon’s Cinema 4D, (You can read Part 1 here.) Part II noted the popularity of Autodesk Maya among character animators and visual effects artists, while Adobe’s game-changing After Effects 2D compositing program became a standard. (You can read Part II here.)

In Part III, let’s look at some of the causes behind the rise in popularity of Cinema 4D, especially among motion graphics producers in New York.

With its many and growing legion of avid users, it’s not easy to miss that Maxon’s Cinema 4D is a highly capable program that contains high-end features well-suited to motion graphics and broadcast designers. While it prices in a similar range to Autodesk Maya—with discounts and upgrade prices that make it even more affordable–the ease with which you can get up to speed when learning Cinema 4D has been a major factor in making it the designer’s favorite 3D app in Gotham.

Surely, that is an important factor and would be reason enough to attract a large base of loyal and devoted users.

However, that doesn’t explain it all. For example, why has Cinema 4D enjoyed success and adoption by studios in New York in spite of such formidable competition from other top notch products including Autodesk 3ds Max, Lightwave, or Softimage — all highly capable and venerable 3D packages in their own right, each of which has it’s own advanced set of features?

I’m not suggesting that almost every design shop in the city uses Cinema 4D exclusively, or even that it is the most popular 3D software in New York today—I don’t have a survey on that. However, I base my opinions on my experience as a freelance motion graphics designer and compositor in New York City for many years working at a variety of studios and production companies. I’ve come to see the remarkable popularity of this software, a program that was relatively little known in the nineties, which seems to be growing with every release, something many of my friends and colleagues also attest too.

(We’d like to know what you think—you can add comments in the section below).

Making the Case

In the previous sections of this series, we have touched on the following points:

• Digital motion designers for the most part began by working with After Effects on the Macintosh sometime during the 1990s (when it was a Mac-only product).

• After Effects users were content to restrict themselves to 2D design and compositing and leave 3D animation to those who specialized in 3D (and vice versa). Neither camp was that interested in each other’s niche since mastering the different programs came only with intense effort.

• After Effects users who wished to do 3D themselves often turned to Specular’s Infini-D to fulfill their 3D requirements. But without a major company behind it, Infini-D eventually vanished from the marketplace, leaving a gaping hole for 3D on the Macintosh platform.

• That many advanced 3D software programs such as Autodesk’s Maya, 3ds max (formerly 3D Studio MAX), Softimage (now owned by Autodesk), and NewTek’s LightWave proliferated on the Windows platform, while few options for capable 3D animation software existed on the Macintosh. This reality resulted initially in a divide between 2D compositing and design (the Mac’s territory) and 3D animation (overwhelmingly based on Windows PCs).

Note: (In his well-researched article in Ars Technica, Dave Girard points out the reasons 3D lagged on the Mac. For example, he notes that until OS X came out, the Mac’s OS wasn’t stable enough nor did it offer the very necessary ability to multi-task. Read more here.)

• Although After Effects was eventually ported to the PC platform along with other graphics mainstays like Photoshop and Illustrator, by and large those in the design community (especially in New York) continued to use the Macintosh as their computing platform in spite of the fact that there was a wealth of high-end 3D software available on the PC platform.

Mac users enter a New Dimension

As we said goodbye to the 1990s, the boom-time of the passing decade was fading, the dot-com bubble had burst and “nine-eleven” was about to darken the palette of colors that would paint the dawn of the new millennium.

But for anyone concerned about advanced graphics, things were getting interesting. After Effects moved beyond flat layers by introducing a 3D camera, Photoshop added a history palette (key for those of us who change our minds), digital video was getting cheaper and easier to work with, and the Internet was connecting all of us in totally new ways.

After Effects’ 3D camera ushered in new possibilities for compositors . Among designers in New York, many After Effects users once content to stay in their 2D niches began casting their eyes longingly towards the world of 3D and imagined how nice it would be if they wouldn’t have to rely on outside 3D animators for every little piece of 3D animation they needed. Wouldn’t it be great if they could start doing some of it themselves? It would probably end up being a whole lot cheaper as well.

They were already developing a sense of working in 3D space due After Effects’ introduction of 3D compositing in version 5 (around 2001). This included the 3D camera, shadow-casting lights, and other features new to After Effects but common to all 3D programs. Although many of us applauded the new 3D capabilities in After Effects, it would be wrong to think of it as a full-featured 3D application. After Effects lacks the sophistication of fully dedicated 3D software such as the ability to model complex geometry and advanced rendering algorithms such as ray tracing. Many referred to the app as working in 2 ½ D space.

Nevertheless motion graphic artists soon began implementing After Effects’ new 3D capabilities, building complex projects with a marked 3D flavor. As a result of these artists becoming more comfortable and familiar working in a 3D environment, the notion of taking the leap into a full 3D production seemed a lot more fathomable than before.

As they looked around for real 3D software to use, they were faced with a question and a dilemma: Which program was good enough, and would it run on their collection of expensive Macintosh hardware? While some Macintosh users switched to Windows apps to take advantage of the rich offerings in 3D software, many design-type folks accustomed to the Mac’s straight forward ease found changing operating systems too daunting. Right or wrong, and well before the PC versus Mac ads hit the airwaves, many in the Apple community were fiercely loyal to the Macintosh.

Stay tuned for the upcoming final segment of our in-depth look at Maxon’s Cinema 4D and its growing popularity in the New York post community. We’ll also review the latest Version 12 of the software.

About Joe Herman

Joe Herman is a filmmaker, artist and post production specialist and writes often about the industry. You can reach him at joe[at]legendmultimedia[dot]com. Or reach and follow him on Twitter @JoeHermanTweets.

Trackbacks

  1. How Cinema 4D Conquered Manhattan - Part II | NYC Production & Post News says:
    10/28/2010 at 12:38 AM

    […] our analysis of the growing popularity of Cinema 4D among motion graphic designers. Read it here. Tweet This Post Tagged as: 3-D, 3D, CGI, graphics, […]

    Reply

Community & Partner Links

How Sony’s New Virtual Sound Technology Can Change How We Hear Films

Kami Asgar and Jessica Parks are post-production heavyweights who work with major studios, namely Sony. As a sound designer (Asgar) and as a post executive (Parks), their collective resume touches on everything from Apocalypto to Grandma’s Boy to Venom.

Parks has recently shifted her focus from supervisor to hands-on sound design, and we talk about how it’s never too late to pivot on your career path and find the thing you love doing wherever you are in life.

Click on this link to read the rest of the article on No Film School’s site.

NJ – Governor Murphy signs $14B Incentive Program Bill – the NJ Economic Recovery Act of 2020

 Film tax credits — amending existing programs to include provisions for so-called New Jersey film partners and New Jersey film-lease partners and allowing an additional $200 million of tax credits annually over 13 years.

Click this link if you want to read the full article on the Lexology site. http://bit.ly/35NtDx6

Film Commish announces date for production restart

In her December 18, 2020 news update, MOME Commissioner Anne del Castillo announced that the Film Office is now accepting permit applications for production activity that begins on July 27th.

She also announced awards now (Awkwafina) and more. To read all of the Film Commish’s bloggy sort of news column, click here.

Stimulus Offers $15 Billion in Relief for Struggling Arts Venues

The coronavirus relief package that Congressional leaders agreed to this week includes grant money that many small proprietors described as a last hope for survival.

For the music venue owners, theater producers and cultural institutions that have suffered through the pandemic with no business, the coronavirus relief package that Congress passed on Monday night offers the prospect of aid at last.

To read the full article on The New York Times’ site, click here.

If you want to start production, here’s the latest news from the Mayor’s Office

Phase 4 production guidance is available on the Film Permit website. All production activity, whether it requires a Film Permit or not, must comply with New York Forward Industry Guidance.

For more information see, please refer to the State Department of Health’s Interim Guidance for Media Production During the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency. Please review the guidelines and FAQ before submitting permit applications. The Film Office is operating remotely, so please allow additional time for Film Permit processing.

The above paragraphs contain links to the various FAQ – just mouse over the relevant words.

Nikon to Stop Making Cameras in Japan

Nikon has fallen on hard times as of late as its camera sales have cratered, and now there’s a new indicator of how dire its financial situation is: the company is reportedly pulling the plug on making cameras in Japan after over 70 years of doing so.

To read the full article on Petapixel’s site, click here.

NVIDIA Uses AI to Slash Bandwidth on Video Calls

NVIDIA Research has invented a way to use AI to dramatically reduce video call bandwidth while simultaneously improving quality

What the researchers have achieved has remarkable results: by replacing the traditional h.264 video codec with a neural network, they have managed to reduce the required bandwidth for a video call by an order of magnitude. In one example, the required data rate fell from 97.28 KB/frame to a measly 0.1165 KB/frame – a reduction to 0.1% of required bandwidth.

To read the rest of this article on Petapixel, click this link.

 

 

 

Union Health Plan Dodges Film Workers’ Suit Over Virus Relief

Law360 (October 9, 2020, 5:22 PM EDT) — The Motion Picture Industry Health Plan’s board can’t be sued under ERISA for allegedly flouting its duties when it relaxed plan rules in response to COVID-19, a California federal judge has ruled, nixing a proposed class action filed by two cinematographers who still couldn’t qualify for benefits.

In an order entered Thursday, U.S. District Judge R. Gary Klausner granted the board of directors’ motion to dismiss Greg Endries and Dee Nichols’ Employee Retirement Income Security Act suit accusing board members of breaching their duty to treat all plan participants fairly.

Endries and Nichols, members of Local 600 of the International Cinematographers Guild, said in July that the board left them and others “out in the cold” in its attempts to address the problems COVID-19 caused for plan participants.

But Judge Klausner agreed with the board’s contention that the case, which alleged a fiduciary breach, should be tossed because plan administrators don’t act as fiduciaries when they amend health care plans.

Read the full article on the Law360 site by clicking here.

Russo Brothers Received Close to $50 Million From Saudi Bank

Anthony Russo and Joseph Russo photographed at the PMC Studio in Los Angeles for the Variety Playback Podcast.

The Russo brothers, directors of the all-time top grossing film “Avengers: Endgame,” quietly secured a roughly $50 million cash infusion for their production company AGBO from Saudi Arabia earlier this year, multiple sources tell Variety.

In a deal brokered and closed at the beginning of the pandemic, the Russos received the investment from an undisclosed Saudi bank in exchange for a minority stake in the brothers’ Los Angeles-based shop.

  • About
  • Archives
  • Advertising
Copyright © 2021 NYCPPNEWS | Site Built with Studio Press Genesis